Julia Angwin, the editor-in-chief and co-founder of the Markup, a still-in-development investigative news publication that was slated to launch in July, has been fired over differences with Sue Gardner, the CEO. The news of Angwin’s ouster, first reported by The New York Times, prompted five of the website’s seven editorial members to announce their resignations. Angwin’s dismissal also drew major public support from the public. Another of its founders, Jeff Larson has been announced as the current editor-in-chief of The Markup.
I’m devastated to have been forced out of the organization I conceived to pursue rigorous, evidence-based tech accountability journalism. I will continue to pursue that mission and I hope to find other ways to build the field. https://t.co/VLWfbmRrKR
— Julia Angwin (@JuliaAngwin) April 23, 2019
I take this responsibility seriously, and am humbled and excited to be the Editor and Chief of The Markup.
— Jeff Larson (@thejefflarson) April 23, 2019
Julia Angwin, an ex-ProPublica veteran had been working alongside Jeff Larson on the Markup for the last year with the vision of producing meaningful data-centered journalism about the impact of technology on society. The Markup raised more than $23 million in funding last year led by Craigslist founder Craig Newmark.
After the news of her oust, Angwin wrote a letter addressed to Newmark, seeking him to review and intervene in the situation unfolding at The Markup. The letter was posted on Twitter from an account named “The Real Team Markup” on Tuesday. Per her letter, Executive Director, Sue Gardner is now seeking to change the mission of the newsroom to “one based on advocacy against the tech companies”. During her interview with candidates Gardner used to ask for their “take” on tech companies, and then reportedly rate them based on their hatred toward these companies. Angwin adds, “She has asked me to run articles with headlines such as ‘Facebook is a dumpster fire’”. On retaliating, Angwin was asked to step down from her position as editor-in-chief on March 29 and become a columnist, writing opinion articles.
Update: The article has now been updated to include Craig Newmark’s response. The story has also been updated on 27th April to include Sue Gardner’s response.
Gardner disputed this characterization to the New York Times. “There is no change in the mission or purpose of The Markup. We are, pure and simple, a news outlet. We always have been and always will be. Our goals and purpose haven’t changed.” she told NYT. The site had issues with Ms. Angwin involving “leadership, management and willingness to accept feedback and training to grow as an editor-in-chief.”
Interestingly, it was Angwin who hired Gardner last year after she forced Angwin to let her become the CEO. Angwin was reluctant but was assured that she would be given an employment contract with job protections for her position as Editor-in-chief but no such contract was signed. Now some people are touting Angwin’s expulsion as a “power grab”.
In disapproval of Angwin’s dismissal, multiple staff members of the Markup have also resigned from their positions. 5 out of 7 editorial team members tweeted about their departure, with Angwin tweeting in response that they “can’t afford to do this. This is heartbreaking.”
Leon can’t afford to resign. This is heartbreaking. https://t.co/AXh85TM1KJ
— Julia Angwin (@JuliaAngwin) April 23, 2019
Adrianne can’t afford to do this. This is heartbreaking. https://t.co/REm2CfDtpe
— Julia Angwin (@JuliaAngwin) April 23, 2019
Surya cannot afford to do this. This is heartbreaking.
(No journalist can afford to quit on principle these days.) https://t.co/OW1TypbT5n
— Julia Angwin (@JuliaAngwin) April 23, 2019
Lauren cannot afford to do this. This is heartbreaking. https://t.co/nzgyoz0YhK
— Julia Angwin (@JuliaAngwin) April 23, 2019
I am so moved and grateful for all the support flooding in.
If ever there was a silver lining in having your dream stolen from you, it is all the love that is coming in. Thank you. https://t.co/FlhTHW4eqe
— Julia Angwin (@JuliaAngwin) April 23, 2019
The Markup is now down to 2 editorial employees. Its response: “Mr. Larson said the company had accelerated recruitment and had ‘multiple other hires in motion,’ and hoped that the launch would not be delayed.”
The editorial team of Markup has also signed a statement of unequivocal support for Julia Angwin.
The editorial team of @team_markup has signed a statement of unequivocal support for our Editor in Chief, @JuliaAngwin: pic.twitter.com/aTRsmM6oeo
— The Real Team Markup (@MarkupReal) April 23, 2019
Other people have also come forward in solidarity with Angwin.
A blog post on Medium opposes her recent ouster as Editor-in-Chief of the Markup and invites people to sign a public statement of support for Julia Angwin. The blog post has been signed by over 100 people and counting, states, “The Markup is set to launch in July and should not do so without Julia at the helm. We encourage all her original funders to investigate this situation and to take steps to ensure that the Markup stays true to its founding principles.”
Journalists and reporters from top publishing sites have also tweeted in support.
The journalists @MarkupReal have done groundbreaking reporting that has set the bar for the rest of us. And their work is so, so needed. What’s happening today means accountability lost or delayed. In a world with too few resources and too little time dedicated already.
— Lois Beckett (@loisbeckett) April 23, 2019
.@JuliaAngwin was the originator of the Pulitzer-finalist series @WhatTheyKnow from 2010-2013 https://t.co/UhaX8hSSLG
She then led the incredibly important work at @ProPubPrivacy looking into bias in algorithms https://t.co/6AtP7ASr1m
This is a terrible move by @team_markup
— ashkan soltani (@ashk4n) April 23, 2019
I am stunned and very sorry to hear of this development in a nascent news organization on which so much hope was resting, in terms of the journalism that it promised to deliver, primarily because of the track record of @JuliaAngwin. https://t.co/uMchDrd9Zf
— Raju Narisetti (@raju) April 23, 2019
Update: Craig Newmark responded yesterday via a tweet saying that “he is taking this very seriously”
I am taking this very seriously. More to come… pic.twitter.com/dXQ6L7BffD
— craig newmark (@craignewmark) April 24, 2019
Craig and Ford Foundation, MacArthur Foundation, Knight Foundation, Open Society Foundation and the Ethics and Governance of AI Initiative will reassess The Markup’s funding.
Update: Sue Gardner has also added her response dismissing all of Jula Angwin’s claims regarding her oust.
Big PR blitz from The Markup, which is now working with a professional comms shop. Extensive on-the-record statements from executive director Sue Gardner disputing each of ousted EIC Julia Angwin's claims. pic.twitter.com/za72PuI5C9
— Peter Sterne (@petersterne) April 26, 2019
Read Next
Google’s Chief Diversity Officer, Danielle Brown resigns to join HR tech firm Gusto
Richard DeVaul, Alphabet executive, resigns after being accused of sexual harassment